When it comes to supplements, can there be too much of a good thing?

Feedmark takes a look at, when it comes to supplements, how much is too much, both when it comes to the volume of supplement that you are feeding and the number of supplements in your routine; and how to simplify your horses daily feeding routine. 

Can You Over-Supplement Your Horse?

Over the past decade, our understanding of equine nutrition has developed considerably. We now have a much greater appreciation of how important good nutrition is in supporting a horse’s natural bodily functions and promoting long-term health and wellbeing.

Alongside this progress, the equine supplement industry has grown, giving horse owners more options than ever when it comes to supporting their horses. It’s now quite common for horses to receive several supplements at once, each chosen with the best intentions. But with so many products available, how can we make sure we’re giving our horses exactly what they need, without giving them too much of a good thing?

When It Comes to Supplements, Can There Be Too Much of a Good Thing?

The answer is yes, but there’s no need to be concerned. With a little knowledge and some careful planning, it’s possible to make the most of supplementation while keeping your horse’s diet balanced and appropriate for their needs.

The key is understanding how much your horse is already receiving, choosing products that complement one another and following the recommended feeding guidelines.

Feeding Too Much of a Supplement

When it comes to supplements, feeding more doesn't necessarily mean getting better results. In many cases, increasing the recommended amount of a product that already has the highest research-backed levels of active ingredients, such as Best Flex HA, is unlikely to provide any additional benefit. It may simply mean using the product up more quickly than necessary.

Some excess nutrients, particularly certain water-soluble vitamins such as those in the B-vitamin family, can be excreted by the body. However, this isn't the case for every nutrient. Feeding excessive amounts of certain vitamins, minerals or herbal ingredients can be harmful and, in some cases, lead to toxicity.

It's also worth remembering that your horse gets nutrients from their forage and other feeds, as well as from supplements. Taking all these sources into account helps ensure they're receiving an appropriate amount of each nutrient, without unnecessary duplication.

Our tip: Always follow the recommended feeding instructions and consider your horse's whole diet before increasing the amount of a supplement or introducing new products.

Feeding Too Many Supplements

Every horse is an individual, with nutritional needs that depend on factors such as age, workload, lifestyle and overall health. A well-balanced diet should provide the essential nutrients needed to support their health and performance, while additional supplements can help address specific needs where appropriate.

The good news is that you don't necessarily need lots of different products to support your horse. A targeted approach, based on their individual requirements, is often the most effective way to supplement.

Feeding several products together can make it harder to keep track of exactly what your horse is receiving. Different supplements may contain the same vitamins, minerals or active ingredients, and these amounts can add up over time.

Taking a little time to review your horse's current feeding routine can help you identify what is working well, where there may be gaps and whether any products are providing overlapping ingredients.

Combining Supplements with Balancers

If your horse receives two or three supplements, it's worth checking their ingredients to make sure they work well together.

This is particularly important when feeding a supplement alongside a feed balancer. Although balancers are often considered part of the daily ration rather than a supplement, they typically contain a range of vitamins and minerals. Some are formulated for particular groups of horses, such as veterans, and may already provide substantial amounts of certain nutrients with added nutraceuticals.

Adding another supplement without reviewing the overall diet could result in your horse receiving more than they need.

Some minerals worth paying particular attention to include:

  • Selenium: Essential for normal bodily function, but the margin between an adequate and excessive intake is relatively narrow.
  • Zinc: Supports normal skin, hoof and immune function. Excessive amounts can interfere with the absorption and use of other minerals.
  • Copper: Important for several bodily processes, but excessive intake can be harmful.
  • Calcium: Essential for healthy bones and normal muscle function, and needs to be balanced appropriately with other minerals, particularly phosphorus.
  • Iron: Needed for normal blood function. Forage often supplies sufficient iron, so additional supplementation is not always necessary.

These minerals all play important roles in maintaining health, but balance is just as important as the amount provided. Depending on the nutrient and the level of intake, excessive amounts may cause digestive problems, interfere with the absorption of other minerals or, in more serious cases, contribute to toxicity or organ damage.

Minerals also interact with one another. For example, an imbalance between zinc and copper can affect how effectively a horse absorbs and uses these nutrients. Calcium and phosphorus also need to be considered together when assessing the overall diet.

The aim is to provide the right nutrients in the right amounts and proportions, rather than simply increasing individual intakes.

Combining Supplements with Medication

Supplements can play a useful role in a horse's feeding routine, but it's important to consider how they might interact with any medication your horse is receiving. Research into supplement and medication interactions in horses is still limited for many ingredients, so seeking advice is always worthwhile.

For example, chaste tree berry (Vitex agnus-castus) is included in some equine supplements marketed for horses with pituitary pars intermedia dysfunction (PPID), commonly known as Cushing's disease. However, potential interactions with prescribed treatments are not fully understood. It should never be used as a replacement for veterinary treatment, and current advise is not to use it alongside medication for PPID or related metabolic conditions.

Another example is devil's claw, a herbal ingredient sometimes used in supplements to maintain joint comfort. Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), such as phenylbutazone (Bute), can irritate the gastrointestinal tract and may contribute to ulcers in some circumstances. As the safety of combining devil's claw with these medications in horses is not well established, it's important to consult your vet before using them together, particularly if your horse has a history of gastric problems.

If your horse receives medication, let your vet know which supplements they're already taking and check with them before introducing anything new. This simple step can help you make informed choices and ensure that all aspects of your horse's care work together.

Are Loading Intakes Necessary?

Some supplements recommend a loading period, during which a higher amount is fed initially before reducing to a lower maintenance intake. The idea is to help the horse achieve an effective level of an active ingredient more quickly.

Whether this is necessary depends on the particular ingredient, the amount provided by the product and the evidence supporting its use. Where a supplement already contains a high level of the active ingredients, a loading period is unlikely to be necessary.

Introducing any new supplement gradually, in line with the manufacturer's guidance, is also a sensible way to help your horse adjust to changes in their diet.

Making the Most of Your Horse's Supplements

With so much information and advice available, choosing supplements can sometimes feel overwhelming. But a few simple checks can help you feel more confident that you're making the right choices for your horse.

Start by reviewing their complete diet, including forage, hard feed, balancers and all supplements. Check product labels for overlapping ingredients and recommended daily amounts, and don't hesitate to contact the manufacturer if you have questions. If you're unsure about your horse's nutritional requirements or possible interactions with medication, your vet or one of Feedmark’s Registered Equine Nutritionists can help assess the diet as a whole.

At Feedmark, we also offer a Bespoke All-in-One, which allows you to combine selected supplement ingredients into one tailored product. This can simplify your horse's daily feeding routine and make it easier to manage multiple supplementation needs in one place.

Ultimately, good supplementation is about giving your horse what they need, rather than simply giving them more. By taking a considered, individual approach, you can make informed decisions, avoid unnecessary duplication and help your horse get the most from their diet.